Case Law

Centre for Child Law Cases

South African Cases

African Cases

South African courts produce a number of judgments relating to the protection and advancement of children’s rights. The Centre is not always involved in cases but sees the importance of judgments coming of cases that it is not involved in. Here you will be provided with a link to a page that contains up to date judgments as well as an archived collection of judgments.

2009 Archive

CASES

Central Authority v B
Reference:
2009 (1) SA 624 (W)
Issue: International Abduction

Hendricks v Thompson
Reference:
[2009] JOL 23016 (T)
Issue: Custody

Hoerskool Ermelo & another v Head, Department of Education, Mapumalanga & Others
Reference:
2009 (3) SA 422 (SCA) | [2009] JOL 23349 (SCA)
Issue: Determination of language policy

Johncom Media Investments Ltd v M and Others (Media Monitoring Project as amicus curiae)
Reference:
2009 (4) SA 7 (CC) | [2009] JOL 23343 (CC)
Issue: Media prohibited from printing names of children in divorce
proceedings in newspapers

Fish Hoek Primary School v Welcome
Reference:
[2009] JOL 23458 (C) | 2009 (3) SA 36 (C)
Issue: Non-custodian parent liable for school fees

Van Zyl v Van Zyl
Reference:
[2009] JOL 23583 (GNP)
Issue: Custody

Murphy v Family Advocate, Cape Town
Reference:
[2009] JOL 23931 (C)
Issue: Wrongful retention of a baby

Mkoka v S
Reference:
[2009] JOL 24007 (ECG)
Issue: Rights of children to parental care

Legal Aid Board v R and Another
Reference:
2009 (2) SA 262 (D)
Issue: Legal representation for children

S v Swartz
Reference:
2009 (1)SACR 452 (C)
Issue: Child witness

S v MBokhani
Reference:
2009 (1) SACR 533 (T)
Issue: Child victim of sexual offence

S v Vilakazi
Reference:
2009 (1) SACR 552 (SCA)
Issue: Minimum sentences

Flynn v Farr No and Others
Reference:
2009 (1) SA 584 (C)
Issue: Definition of adopted child

DPP, Transvaal V Minister of Jutsice and Constitutional Development, and Others
Reference:
2009 (4) 222 (CC)
Issue: Child witnesses; child victims and the CPA

AS v Vorster NO and others
Reference:
2009 (4) SA 108 (SE) |[2009] ZAECHC 26
Issue: Adoption-withdrawal of consent

Makhuvela obo Hempe v RAF
Reference:
[2009] JOL 23697 (GSJ) | [2009] ZAGPJHC 18
Issue: Foster care grant

Katz v Katz
Reference:
[2009] JOL 23557 (GSJ)
Issue: Relocation/variation of custody

S v Geldenhuys
Reference:
2009 (1) SACR 1 (SCA) | [2008] ZASCA 47 | [2008] 3 All SA 8 (SCA)
Issue: Sexual offences: age of consent

2008 Archive

CASES

MEC for Education, KZN and others v Pillay (Governing Body Foundation (1st amicus curiae), Natal Tamil Vedic Society Trust (2nd amicus curiae), Freedom from Expression Institute (3rd amicus curiae)
Reference:
[2008] JOL 20810 (CC) | [2007] ZACC 21 | [2008] (1) SA 474 (CC); | [2008] (2) BCLR 99 (CC)
Issue: Religious and cultural practices

AD and another v DW and others, Centre for Child Law (amicus curiae); Dept of Social Development (intervening)
Reference:
[2008] JOL 21203 (CC) | [2008 (4) BCLR 359 (CC) | [2007] ZACC 27 | 2008 (3) SA 183 (CC)
Issue: Adoption by foreign nationals

S v Sikhunana
Reference:
[2008] JOL 21278 (E)
Issue: Theft by minor

Gerber v Gerber and Another
Reference:
[2008] JOL 21304 (C) | [2007] ZAWCHC 65
Issue: Maintenance

Hepburn v Miller
Reference:
[2008] JOL 21354 (W) | [2007] ZAGPHC 301
Issue: Custody

Blumenow v Blumenow
Reference:
[2008] JOL 21382 (W)
Issue: Custody, best interests of the child

State v Mshumpa and Another
Reference:
[2008] JOL 21411 (ELC) | [2007] ZAECHC 23
Issue: Killing an unborn child

Bestuursraad van Laerskool Sentraal, Kakamas v Van Kradenburg en ‘n Ander
Reference:
[2008] JOL 21631 (NC) | [2008] ZANCHC 18
Issue: Payment of school fees, custody

Coetsee v Coetsee
Reference:
[2008] JOL 21789 (T) | [2008] ZAGPHC 126
Issue: Custody

Joubert v Joubert
Reference:
[2008] JOL 21929 (C)
Issue: Custody

S v Mokoena, S v Phaswane
Reference:
[2005] JOL 21960 (T) | [2008] ZAGPHC 148
Issue: Criminal justice system and rights of children

Hardwick v Hardwick
Reference:
[2008] JOL 21973 (N) | [2008] ZAKZHC 43
Issue: Custody

Moodley v Moodley
Reference:
[2008] JOL 22100 (SE) | [2008] ZAKZHC 48
Issue: Interim custody

Central Authority for the RSA v Bronowicki
Reference:
[2008] JOL 22278 (W) | [2009] (1) SA 624 (W) | [2008] ZAGPHC 261
Issue: International child abduction

Alberts v Alberts
Reference:
[2008] JOL 22282 (T)
Issue: Custody

Mose (legal Guardian of Luzuko Mose) v Minister of Education, Provincial Government of the Western Cape, Garu and Others
Reference:
[2008] JOL 22623 (C) | [2008] ZAWCHC 56 | 2009 (2) SA 408 (C)
Issue: Expulsion from school

Lothian v Valentine
Reference:
[2008] JOL 22678 (ZH) | [2007] ZWHHC 78
Issue: Guardianship

Centre for Child Law v Minister for Justice and Constitutional Development and Others
Reference:
[2008] JOL 22687 (T) | [2009] ZACC 18 | [2009] (2) SACR 477 (CC) | [2009] (6) SA 632 (CC) | [2009] (11) BCLR 1105 (CC)
Issue: Minimum sentencing of minors

M v S (Centre for Child Law as Amicus Curiae)
Reference:
[2008] (5) BCLR 475 (CC) | [2007] ZACC 18 | [2008] (3) SA 232 (CC)
Issue: Best interests of the child, sentencing the primary care giver

J v J
Reference:
2008 (6) SA 30 (CC) | [2008] ZAWCHC 27
Issue: Custody

Fosi v RAF and Another
Reference:
2008 (3) SA 560 (CC) | [2007] ZAWCHC 8
Issue: Duty of child to support parent in terms of customary law

S v Mokoena
Reference:
2008 (5) SA 578 (T) | [2009] ZAFSHC 135
Issue: Child witnesses

2007 Archive

CASES

Stemmet v Stemmet
Reference:
2006 JDR 0126 (T) | [2007] JOL 18938 (T)
Issue: Access

Kleingeld v Heunis
Reference:
[2007] (5) SA 559 (T) | [2007] JOL 18983 (T)
Issue: Access

De Beer v De Beer
Reference:
[2006] JDR 1046 (T) | [2007] JOL 18954 (T)
Issue: Custody

Steyn v Hofmänner
Reference:
[2007] JOL 19006 (C)
Issue: Rights of the father

Central Authority v Houwert
Reference:
[2007] JOL 19233 (T) | [2008] (1) SA 49 (SCA)
Issue: Abduction

Wessels and another v Wessels
Reference:
[2007] JOL 19295 (T)
Issue: Maintenance

Potgieter v Potgieter
Reference:
[2007] JOL 19597 (SCA) | [2007] 3 All SA 9 (SCA)
Issue: Custody

Beckford v Beckford
Reference:
[2008] JDR 0070 (ZH) | [2007] JOL 19623 (ZH)
Issue: Custody

Hoerskool Ermelo en ‘n Ander v Departementshoof, Mpumalanga Departement van Onderwys en Andere
Reference:
[2007] JOL 19629 (T)
Issue: Language in schools

Kalimashe v Macanda
Reference:
[2007] JOL 19765 (E) | [2007] 4 All SA 883 (E)
Issue: Custody and the best interests of the Child

De Gree and another v Webb and Others (Centre for Child Law as amicus curiae)
Reference:
[2007] (5) SA 184 (SCA) | [2007] JOL 20023 (SCA)
Issue: International adoption

Central Authority v Van Hanxleden Houwert
Reference:
2007 JDR 0451 (SCA) | [2007] JOL 20032 (SCA)
Issue: Child abduction

Mtshingwe v Moyo
Reference:
[2007] JOL 20114 (ZH)
Issue: Paternity disputes

Tame v Tame and Others
Reference:
[2007] JDR 0880 (T) | [2007] JOL 20647 (T)
Issue: Custody

Family Advocate v B
Reference:
[2007] 1 All SA 602 (SE)
Issue: Abduction

Family advocate, Port Elizabeth v Hide
Reference:
[2007] 3 All SA 248 (SE)
Issue: Abduction

Ex Parte Leask and Others
Reference:
[2007] 4 All SA 1018 (D)
Issue: Adoption

Forssmen v Forssmen
Reference:

[2007] 4 All SA 1145 (SCA) | [2008] (2)SA 144 (W) | [2007] ZAGPHC 156
Issue: Maintenance

M v S (Centre for child law: amicus curiae)
Reference:
[2007] (12) BCLR 1312 (CC) | [2007] (2) SACR 539 (CC)
Issue: Sentencing a primary caregiver and the best interests of the child

S v H
Reference:
2007 (3) SA 330 (C)
Issue: International abduction

P v P
Reference:
2007 (5) SA 94 (SCA)
Issue: Custody

De Gree and Another v Webb and others (Centre for child law as Amicus Curiae)
Reference:
2007 (5) SA 184 (SCA)
Issue: Inter – country adoption

Central Authority (SA) v A
Reference:
[2007] (5) SA 501 (W)
Issue: International abduction

F v F
Reference:
2007 (3) SA 42 (SCA)
Issue: Relocation

2006 Archive

CASES

S v Meje and others
Reference:
[2006] JOL 16020 (E)
Issue: Child offender

Brown v Stone / B v S
Reference:
[2005] JOL 16286 (SCA) | [2006] 4 All SA 515 (SCA) | [2005] JDR 1438 (SCA)
Issue: Access in foreign country

Senior Family Advocate, Cape Town and another v Houtman
Reference:
[2006] JOL 16644 (C) | [2004] (6) SA 274 (C)
Issue: Abduction

Ford v Ford
Reference:
[2006] JOL 16676 (W)
Issue: Relocation of minor

Radebe v S
Reference:
[2006] JOL 16688 (T)
Issue: Minimum sentence applied to minor

Smit v Malan
Reference:
2005 JDR 0690 (T) | [2006] JOL 16715 (T)
Issue: Access

S v Dyomfana
Reference:
[2006] JOL 16735 (Tk)
Issue: Criminal prosecution of a minor

S v Khumalo
Reference:
[2006] JDR 0147 (T) | [2006] JOL 16890 (T)
Issue: Assault by minor

Tilo v S
Reference:
[2006] (2) SACR 266 (NC) | [2006] JOL 16948 (NC)
Issue: Custody

Family Advocate, Cape Town and Another v Chirome aka Munyuki
Reference:
[2006] JOL 17112 (C)
Issue: International child abduction

Boekmke v McGreger / B v M
Reference:
[2006] JOL 17154 (W) | [2006] 3 All SA 109 (W) | [2006] (9) BCLR 1034 (W)
Issue: Relocation, custody

Lombard v Lombard
Reference:
[2006] JOL 17210 (SE)
Issue: Maintenance

De Gree and Another v Webb and Others
Reference:
[2006] (6) SA 51 (W) | [2006] JOL 17223 (W)
Issue: Inter-country adoption

94.7 Highveld Stereo v Olivier and Another
Reference:
[2006] JOL 17272 (BCCSA)
Issue: Protection of children

Botha v Botha
Reference:
[2006] (4) SA 144 (SCA) | [2006] JOL 17473 (T)
Issue: Access and custody

Lindsay v Otten
Reference:
[2006] JOL 17489 (N)
Issue: Maintenance

S v Nkosi
Reference:
[2006] JOL 17717 (T)
Issue: Theft by minor

S v Valtein and Another
Reference:
[2006] JOL 17752 (E)
Issue: Child offender

Pillay v Kwa-Zulu Natal MEC of Education, Cronje and Others
Reference:
[2006] JOL 17833 (N) | [2006] (10) BCLR 1237 (W)
Issue: Discrimination

Jansen v Jansen
Reference:
[2006] JOL 17978 (T)
Issue: Custody

Ndaba v Ndaba
Reference:
[2006] JOL 17986 (T)
Issue: Custody

Family Advocate v Bailie
Reference:
[2006] JOL 18610 (SE)
Issue: International abduction

Rosen v Havenge
Reference:
[2006] 4 All SA 199 (C)
Issue: Custody and access

Seodin Primary School and Others v MEC for Education Northern Cape and Others
Reference:
[2006] 1 All SA 154 (NC) | 2006 (4) BCLR 542 (NC)
Issue: Language in Schools

DPP, KZN v P
Reference:
[2006] (3) SA 515 (SCA)
Issue: Child offender

B v S
Reference: [
2006] (5) SA 42 (SCA)
Issue: International abduction

S v B
Reference:
[2006] (1) SACR 311 (SCA)
Issue: Minimum sentences -16 and 17 year olds

S v Koralev and Another
Reference:
2006 (2) SACR 298 (N)
Issue: Child pornography

S v Mojaki
Reference:
[2006] (2) SACR 590 (T)
Issue: Childrens court enquiry

2005 Archive

CASES

Taljaard v Fuchs
Reference:
[2005] JOL 13199 (T)
Issue: Access

L v L
Reference:
[2005] JOL 13310 (W)
Issue: Custody

S v Mhlawuli and Others
Reference:
[2005] JOL 13525 (TK)
Issue: Sentencing of child offenders

S v Ross
Reference:
[2005] JOL 13739 (E)
Issue: Maintenance obligation

S v Slamdill
Reference:
[2005] JOL 13780 (E)
Issue:
Sentencing, reform school

Ngcobo and Another v S
Reference:
Ngcobo and Another v S
Issue: Murder by minors

S v Monkayi
Reference:
[2005] JOL 14003 (E)
Issue: Sentencing

Fraser v S
Reference:
[2005] JOL 14045 (SCA)
Issue: Kidnapping by biological father

S v Mbikwa
Reference:
[2005] JOL 14076 (E)
Issue: Sentencing

Ex parte Van Niekerk and another: In re Van Niekerk v Van Niekerk
Reference:
[2005] JOL 14218 (T)
Issue: Access

S v Moyakhe and Another
Reference:
[2005] JOL 14361 (E)
Issue: Assault

S v S
Reference:
[2005] JOL 14428 (T)
Issue: Incest, custody

S v M and another
Reference:
[2005] JOL 14493 (T)
Issue: Shoplifting by minors

S v M
Reference:
[2005] JOL 144543 (T)
Issue: Housebreaking

S v Davids
Reference:
[2005] JOL 14626 (E)
Issue: Law relating to children

Honi v RAF
Reference:
[2005] JOL 14789 (E)
Issue: Motor collision involving a minor

S v Mathebula
Reference:
[2005] JOL 14806 (T)
Issue: Sentencing

Laubuschagne v Laubuschagne
Reference:
[2005] JOL 14865 (E)
Issue: Custody

Martizburg College v Dlamini NO and Others
Reference:
[2005] JOL 15075 (N)
Issue: Expulsion

Clark v Clark
Reference:
[2005] JOL 15108 (D)
Issue: Custody

Kahn v Kahn
Reference:
[2005] JOL 15142 (T)
Issue: Access

S v Masibi
Reference:
[2005] JOL 15159 (T)
Issue: Access

Rosen v Havenga and Another
Reference:
[2005] JOL 15235 (C)
Issue: Access, sole custody and Guardianship, legal representative for the child

S v Malungana

Reference: [2005] JOL 15254 (T)
Issue: Sentencing of children

Rovetto v Walter-Rovetto
Reference:
[2005] JOL 15303 (T)
Issue: Abduction

S v Ncula
Reference:
[2005] JOL 15361 (E)
Issue: Drug dealing

S v Hlam and Another
Reference:
[2005] JOL 15455 (TK)
Issue: Unlawful possession of a fire arm by a minor

Memela v Memela
Reference:
[2005] JOL 15469 (TK)
Issue: Custody

S v Ndlovu
Reference:
[2005] JOL 15604 (T)
Issue: Child offenders

Omar v Government of South Africa
Reference:
[2005] 2 All SA 65 (N)
Issue: Domestic violence

Brandt v S
Reference:
[2005] 1 All SA 1 (SCA)
Issue: Sentencing of child offenders

Governing Body Mikro Primary School and Another v Minister of Education, Western Cape and Others
Reference:
[2005] JOL 13716 (C) | [2005] 2 All SA 37 (C)
Issue: Education

S v Frazer
Reference:
2005 (1) SACR 455 (SCA)
Issue: Kidnapping

S v Manqaba
Reference:
[2005] (2) SACR 489 (W)
Issue: Child witnesses

Eskom Holdings LTD v Hendricks
Reference:
[2005] (5) 503 (SCA)
Issue: Child criminal capacity

Centre for Child Law and Another v Minister of Home Affairs and Others
Reference:
[2005] (6) SA 50 (T)
Issue: Lindela case, unaccompanied foreign minors

R v H and Another
Reference:
[2005] (6) SA 535 (C)
Issue: Access by non-custodial parent

2004 Archive

CASES

Esterhuizen v Fouche
Reference:
[2004] JOL 12405 (T)
Issue: Custody

Laubscher v Laubscher
Reference:
[2004] JOL 12451 (T)
Issue: Access

S v Bhembe
Reference:
[2004] JOL 12604 (T)
Issue: Assault by a minor

S v Woniwe
Reference:
[2004] JOL 12050 (C)
Issue: Rape or consensual sex with a minor

Ford v Ford
Reference:
[2004] JOL 12665 (W) | [2004] 2 All SA 396 (W)
Issue: Custody, relocation

Tyler and Another v Tyler and others
Reference:
[2004] JOL 12703 (NC)
Issue: Custody

S v Bhogwana and Another
Reference:
[2004] JOL 12833 (TK)
Issue: Theft

Christian Lawyers’ Association v National Minister of Health and Others
Reference:
[2004] JOL 12853 (T)
Issue: Abortion

Joubert v Joubert
Reference:
[2004] JOL 12900 (T)
Issue: Custody, relocation

S v Mongwe
Reference:
[2004]JOL 12977 (T)
Issue: Contempt of court by a child offender

Brandt v S
Reference:
[2004] JOL 13262 (SCA)
Issue: Murder by a minor

Peterson v Maintenance Officer
Reference:
[2004] 1 All SA 117 (C)
Issue: Maintenance

Townsend-Turner and Another v Marrow
Reference:
[2004] 1 All SA 235 (C)
Issue: Access to grandchildren

Brown v Abrahams and Others
Reference:
[2004] (4) BCLR 348 (C)
Issue: Abduction

Governing body, Gene Louw Primary School v Roodtman
Reference:
[2004] (1) SA 45 (CC)
Issue: School fees

S v Z and 23 Similar Cases
Reference:
[2004] (1) SACR 400 (E)
Issue: Lack of reform schools – detaining children awaiting trial

De Reuck v DPP, Witwatersrand Local Division and Others
Reference:
[2004] (1) SA 406 (CC)
Issue: Child pornography

Pennello v Pennello
Reference:
[2004] (3) SA 100 (N)
Issue: International Abduction

Senior Family Advocate, Cape Town and Another v Houtman
Reference:
[2004] (6) SA 274 (CC)
Issue: International Abduction

2003 Archive

CASES

S v Sikhosana
Reference:
[2003] JOL 10457 (T)
Issue: Rights of a minor accused

Domingo v S
Reference:
[2003] JOL 10502 (C) | [2003] (2) BCLR 213 (C)
Issue: Assault on a minor by the minors father

Myburgh v Myburgh
Reference:
[2003] JOL 10545 (E)
Issue: Maintenance, reasonable needs of the child

Talbot v Cleverly and Another
Reference:
[2003] JOL 10608 (W) | [2003] 1 All SA 640 (W)
Issue: Illegitimate child and the rights of the father

Galante v Galante
Reference:
[2003] JOL 10667 (ZH)
Issue: Custody

Nyamimba v S
Reference:
[2003] JOL 10677 (ZH)
Issue:
Rape of a minor

Pennello v Pennello
Reference:
[2003] JOL 10725 (N) | [2003] 1 All SA 716 (N)
Issue: Custody, abduction

Rudolph v Van Zyl
Reference:
[2003] JOL 10893 (T)
Issue: Rights of access

Roels v Roels
Reference:
[2003] JOL 10910 (C)
Issue: Maintenance

Nortje v S
Reference:
[2003] JOL 10938 (ZH)
Issue: Child pedestrian, drivers duty of care

Jere v Chitsunge
Reference:
[2003] JOL 10941 (ZH)
Issue: Custody

S v Jantjies
Reference:
[2003] JOL 10981 (E)
Issue: Child abandonment

S v Gumede
Reference:
[2003] JOL 11007 (ZH)
Issue: Fining a child offenders

S v Sontlaba
Reference:
[2003] JOL 11023 (TK)
Issue: Murder by minor

Krugel v Krugel
Reference:
[2003] JOL 11028 (T)
Issue: Custody

S v Mdibaniso and Another
Reference:
[2003] JOL 11078 (E)
Issue: Theft by a minor

S v Potse
Reference:
[2003] JOL 11151 (O)
Issue: Rape of an infant

Van der Berg v Le Roux
Reference:
[2003] JOL 11154 (NC) | [2003] 3 All SA 599 (NC)
Issue: Custody

Gumede v S
Reference:
[2003] JOL 11186 (SCA)
Issue: Rape of and testamentary by a minor

S v Milo
Reference:
[2003] JOL 11328 (T)
Issue: Rape of a minor

S v Prins
Reference:
[2003] JOL 11418 (C)
Issue: Abandonment of children

S v Mabujani and others
Reference:
[2003] JOL 11453 (E)
Issue: Sentencing minors

Kotze v Kotze
Reference:
[2003] JOL 11479 (T)
Issue: Custody, religion

S v Mathebule
Reference:
[2003] JOL 11494 (T)
Issue: Theft by minor

S v Senyolo and Another
Reference:
[2003] JOL 11520 (T)
Issue: Sentencing

Olwagen v Olwagen
Reference:
[2003] JOL 11541 (SE)
Issue: Custody

Mdluli v S
Reference:
[2003] JOL 11653 (N)
Issue: Duty of child maintenance

Ntuli v Zulu and Others
Reference:
[2003] JOL 11654 (N)
Issue: Custody

Mpengu v S
Reference:
[2003] JOL 11656 (E)
Issue: Rape and incest by minor

Du Preez v S
Reference:
[2003] JOL 11734 (E)
Issue: Maintenance

Qoza v Qoza
Reference:
[2003] JOL 11786 (TK)
Issue: Maintenance

S v Zuba + 23 similar cases
Reference:
[2003] JOL 11973 (E) | 2004 (4) BCLR 410 (E)
Issue: Sentencing of child offenders

S v Pilusa
Reference:
[2003] JOL 12031 (T)
Issue: Rights of minor accused

Townsend-Turner and Another v Morrow
Reference:
[2003] JOL 12035 (C)
Issue: Grandparents right to access

Katedza v Chunga and Another
Reference:
[2003] JOL 12040 (ZH)
Issue: Rights of the father

Hay v Brown and Others
Reference:
[2003] JOL 12167 (W)
Issue: Refusal by parents to grant blood transfusion

S v Mhaqa and Another
Reference:
[2003] JOL 12193 (TK)
Issue: Unrepresented youth offenders

Pennello v Pennello and Another
Reference:
[2003] JOL 12205 (SCA) | 2004 (3) BCLR 243 (SCA)
Issue: Abduction

Kwenamore v S
Reference:
[2003] JOL 12216 (SCA)
Issue: Housebreaking by a minor

S v Rayi
Reference:
[2003] JOL 12339 (E)
Issue: Sentencing

Jappie v Cooper
Reference:
[2003] JOL 12375 (W)
Issue: Guardianship

S v Nkosi
Reference:
[2003] JOl 12399 (T)
Issue: Unlawful possession of ammunition by a minor

Bannatyne v Bannatyne and Another
Reference:
[2003] (2) BCLR 111 (CC)
Issue: Right of children to parental care

S v B
Reference:
2003 (1) SA 552 (SCA)
Issue: Child witness

S v Kondile
Reference:
[2003] (2) SACR 510 (CC)
Issue: Child witness

Du Toit and Another v Minister of Welfare and Population Development and others (lesbian and Gay Equality Project as Amicus Curiae)
Reference:
[2003] (2) SA 198 (CC)
Issue: Adoption-same sex couple

T v C and Another
Reference:
2003 (2) SA 298 (W)
Issue: Adoption – Notice to natural father

Chief Family Advocate and Another v G
Reference:
[2003] (2) SA 599 (W)
Issue: International Abduction

De Reuck v DPP, Witwatersrand Local Division and Others
Reference:
[2003] (3) SA 389 (W)
Issue: Child pornography

Kotze v Kotze
Reference:
[2003] (3) SA 628 (T)
Issue: Child’s right to freedom of religion vs parent’s right to choose a child’s religion

Laerskool Middelburg en ‘n Ander v Department Hoof, Mpumalanga Departement van Onderwys, Andere
Reference:
[2003] (4) SA 160 (T)
Issue: Right to education

DPP, KZN v Mekka
Reference:
2003 (4) SA 275 (SCA)
Issue: Child witness

Soller NO v G and Another
Reference:
[2003] (5) SA 430 (W)
Issue: Legal representation for children

J and Another v D-G, Dept of Home Affairs, and Others
Reference:
[2003] (5) SA 605 (D)
Issue: Registration of child born out wedlock-same sex couple

2002 Archive

CASES

Jackson v Jackson
Reference:
[2002] JOL 9229 (A)
Issue: Custody

Schlaphoff v Dunn
Reference:
[2002] JOL 9279 (SE)
Issue: Custody

Heystek v Heystek
Reference:
[2002] JOL 9297 (T) | [2002] 2 All SA 22 (C)
Issue: Maintenance of step children

Campos v S
Reference:
[2002] JOL 9361 (A)
Issue: Murder of a child

Swarts v Swarts and Others
Reference:
[2002] JOL 9381 (T) | [2002] 3 All SA 55 (T)
Issue: Removal of child to place of safety

Narodien v Andrew
Reference:
[2002] JOL 9420 (C)
Issue: Variation of protection order, custody

S v Sengani
Reference:
[2002] JOL 9561 (T)
Issue: Assault by a child

Munukwa v S
Reference:
[2002] JOL 9585 (ZH)
Issue: Sentencing of child offenders

S v Booysen
Reference:
[2002] JOL 9610 (NC)
Issue: Trial of a minor

S v Van Rooyen
Reference:
[2002] JOL 9613 (CC)
Issue: Sentencing of child offenders

Grobbelaar v Grobbelaar
Reference:
[2002] JOL 9617 (T)
Issue: Maintenance, private school

S v Kheswa
Reference:
[2002] JOL 9629 (T)
Issue:
Child abuse

S v Nkosi
Reference:
[2002] JOL 9731 (T)
Issue: Child offenders

Reinach v Carstens
Reference:
[2002] JOL 9877 (T)
Issue: Access to children, emigration

Uys v Uys
Reference:
[2002] JOL 10011 (T)
Issue: Custody

S v Nkumbule
Reference:
[2002] JOL 10031 (T)
Issue: Sentencing juveniles

Musasa v S
Reference:
[2002] JOL 10072 (ZH)
Issue: Credibility of a child witness

S v Pako
Reference:
[2002] JOL 10105 (T)
Issue: Criminal capacity of a minor

Meyers v Meyers
Reference:
[2002] JOL 10333 (SE)
Issue: Maintenance

S v Chuma and Another
Reference:
[2002] JOL 10415 (T)
Issue: Minors gambling

Ex Parte Oppel and Another
Reference:
[2002] 2 All SA 8 (C)
Issue: Application of a curator ad litem

Belo v Commissioner for Child Welfare
Reference:
[2002] 3 All SA 286 (W)
Issue: Adoption

Treatment Action Campaign and Others v Minister of Health and Others
Reference:
2002 (4) BCLR 356 (T)
Issue: Access to health services, mother to child transmission of HIV

Treatment Action Campaign and Others v Minister of Health and Others (1)
Reference:
2002 (10) BCLR 1033 (CC)
Issue: Access to health services, mother to child transmission of HIV

Andrews v Narodien
Reference:
2002 (1) SACR 336 (CC)
Issue: Access to child: Domestic Violence

Swarts v Swarts en Andere
Reference:
[2002] (3) SA 451 (T)
Issue: Form 4 removal

P and Another v P and Another
Reference:
2002 (6) SA 105 (N)
Issue: Relocation: Child living with uncle and aunt who wish to relocate; biological parents object

S v Ngobese and Others
Reference:
2002 (1) SACR 562 (W)
Issue: Child offender- criminal capacity – proof of doli capax

2001 Archive

CASES 2001

Hingeston v Lightfoot
Reference:
[2001] JOL 7653 (ZS)
Issue: Education

S v Pedro
Reference:
[2001] JOL 7701 (C)
Issue: Sentencing a minor

S v Sikhumba
Reference:
[2001] JOL 7763 (TK)
Issue: Assessment of child witnesses

Peterson and Another v S
Reference:
[2001] JOL 7775 (C) | [2001] 2 All SA 349 (A)
Issue: Sentencing of youth offenders

Heynike v Roets
Reference:
[2001] JOL 7821 (C) | [2001] 2 All SA 79 (C)
Issue: Custody and the emigration of the custodian

Van Rooyen v Van Rooyen
Reference:
[2001] JOL 7826 (T) | [2001] 2 All SA 37 (T)
Issue: Custody to same sex couple

S v Katu
Reference:
[2001] JOL 7852 (EC)
Issue: Sentencing of youth offender

Latouf v Latouf
Reference:
[2001] JOL 7881 (T) | [2001] 2 All SA 377 (T)
Issue: Custody

S v Teyise
Reference:
[2001] JOL 7918 (CK)
Issue: Sentencing of youth offender

Smith v Smith
Reference:
[2001] JOL 8055 (A) | [2001] 3 All SA 146 (A)
Issue: Custody

Lubbe v du Plessis
Reference:
[2001] JOL 8220 (C)
Issue: Custody

S v Mgxaboyi
Reference:
[2001] JOL 8241 (TK)
Issue: Minor accused

S v Ngubo
Reference:
[2001] JOL 8258 (TK)
Issue: Minor accused

S v Morrie
Reference:
[2001] JOL 8262 (E)
Issue: Child offender

Harris v Minister of Education
Reference:
[2001] JOL 8310 (T) | 2001 (8) BCLR 796 (T)
Issue: Age of admission to school

S v Banda
Reference:
[2001] JOL 8352 (ZH)
Issue: Abortion

Makuni v Makuni
Reference:
[2001] JOL 8357 (ZH)
Issue: Custody

S v Nzara
Reference:
[2001] JOL 8529 (ZH)
Issue: Rape of minor where the accused was HIV positive

S v Chibate
Reference:
[2001] JOL 8539 (ZH)
Issue: Concealment of the birth of a child

Brandt v Brandt
Reference:
[2001] JOL 8644 (C)
Issue: Duty to maintain child

S v Maqungo
Reference:
[2001] JOL 8999 (TK)
Issue: Theft by a minor

Mendela v Mendela
Reference:
[2001] JOL 9020 (TK)
Issue: Custody

Joubert and Another v Jacobs
Reference:
[2001] JOL 9024 (SE)
Issue: Custody

S v Botha
Reference:
[2001] All SA 527 (E)
Issue: Arrears in child maintenance

S v Blaau
Reference:
[2001] (2) SACR 255 (CC)
Issue: Minimum sentence – Semble
on 16 and 17 year olds

Sonderup v Tondelli and Another
Reference:
2001 (1) SA 1171 (CC)
Issue: International Abduction

Schutte v Jacobs (nr1)
Reference:
[2001] (2) SA 470 (W)
Issue: Relocation

H v R
Reference:
[2001] (3) SA 623 (CC)
Issue: Relocation

Metiso v Padongelukfonds
Reference:
[2001] (3) SA 1142 (T)
Issue: Adoption- customary law

2000 Archive

CASES

Christian Education SA v Minister of Education of the Government of the Republic of South Africa
Reference:
[2000] JOL 5892 (SE) | [1999] (9) BCLR 951 (SE)
Issue: Corporal punishment

Hingeston v Lightfoot
Reference:
[2000] JOL 5900 (ZH)
Issue: Maintenance of children

Jooste v Botha
Reference:
[2000] JOL 5943 (T) | [2000] (2) BCLR 187 (T)
Issue: Duty to love, parental duty

S v Daniels
Reference:
[2000] JOL 6150 (C)
Issue: Abandonment of children

Fitzpatrick and Others v Minister of Social Welfare and Pensions
Reference:
[2000] JOL 6250 (C) | [2000] 1 ALL SA 581 (C)
Issue: Adoption

S v Sohlezi
Reference:
[2000] JOL 6256 (NC)
Issue: Failure to pay maintenance

Crone v Crone
Reference:
[2000] JOL 6395 (ZS)
Issue: Maintenance

Hardy v Skaramangas
Reference:
[2000] JOL 6446 (ZH)
Issue: Custody

Goto v Goto
Reference:
[2000] JOL 6472 (ZH)
Issue: Custody

S v Uys
Reference:
[2000] JOL 6482
Issue: Maintenance

Hughson and Another v Greyling
Reference:
[2000] JOL 6608 (ZH)
Issue: Custody

Minister for Welfare and Population Development v Fitzpatrick and others
Reference:
[2000] JOL 6689 (CC) | 2000 (2) BCLR 713 (CC)
Issue: Adoption

S v Buys
Reference:
[2000] JOL 7031 (T)
Issue: Rape of a minor

Schutte v Jacobs
Reference:
[2000] JOL 7099 (W)
Issue: Custody

S v Mauk
Reference:
[2000] JOL 7107 (W)
Issue: Incest and rape of a minor

Faram v Faram
Reference:
[2000] JOL 7179 (ELC)
Issue: Custody

Smith v Goddard
Reference:
[2000] JOL 7202 (N)
Issue: Custody, challenge to the maternal preference rule

Christian Education South Africa v Minister of Education
Reference:
[2000] JOL 7320 (CC)| [2000] (10) BCLR 1051 (CC)
Issue: Corporal punishment

S v Pono
Reference:
[2000] JOL 7423 (CK)
Issue: Trial of a minor

Allsop v McCann
Reference:
[2000] 3 All SA 475 (C)
Issue: Education

S v Baloyi
Reference:
[2000] (1) BCLR 86 (CC)
Issue: Family violence

S v K
Reference:
[2000] (4) BCLR 405 (NMS)
Issue: Cautionary rule

Van Tonder v Van Tonder
Reference:
2000 (1) SA 529 (O)
Issue: Custody-removal of child by non-custodial parent

Patel and Another v Minister of Home Affairs and Another
Reference:
[2000] (2) SA 343 (D)
Issue: Right to parental care

I v S
Reference:
[2000] (2) SA 993 (CC)
Issue: Access: child’s views

WS v LS
Reference:
[2000] (4) SA 104 (CC)
Issue: International abduction

S v Nkosi En ‘N Ander
Reference:
[2000] (2) SACR 94 (T)
Issue: Child offender – sentence

1999 Archive

CASES

Critchfield v Critchfield
Reference:
[1999] JOL 4325 (W) | [1999] 1 All SA 319 (W)
Issue: Custody

King v Dengo
Reference:
[1999] JOL 4469 (SH)
Issue: Sex with a minor

S v Zingela, Gelebe, Nyila, Magi, Mngomezulu and Another
Reference:
[1999] JOL 4536 (E)
Issue: Theft by minor

Bentley and Another v McPherson
Reference:
[1999] JOL 4563 (EC) | [1999] 2 All SA 89 (E)
Issue: Kidnapping

Murray v S
Reference:
[1999] JOL 4571 (W)
Issue: Failure to pay maintenance

Kirsh v Kirsh
Reference:
[1999] JOL 4642 (C)
Issue: Failure to pay maintenance

Kilian v S
Reference:
[1999] JOL 4643 (T)
Issue: Failure to pay maintenance

S v Majiet
Reference:
[1999] JOL 4651 (C)
Issue: Maintenance

Bursey v Bursey and another
Reference:
[1999] JOL 4717 (A) | [1999] 2 All SA 289
Issue:

S v Marema and Others
Reference:
[1999] JOL 4807 (T)
Issue: Sentencing of minors

Van Tonder v Van Tonder
Reference:
[1999] JOL 4958 (O)
Issue: Custody

Mukheiber v Raath and Another
Reference:
[1999] JOL 5009 (A) | [1999] 3 All SA 490 (A)
Issue: Wrongful birth

Bebb v Bebb
Reference:
[1999] JOL 5102 (SE)
Issue: Custody

Bruckner v Bruckner and Another
Reference:
[1999] JOL 5108 (SE) | [1998] 3 All SA 544 (C)
Issue: Access

Mavis (a child offender) v S
Reference:
[1999] JOL 5182 (ZH)
Issue: Arrest

S v Zitha and Others
Reference:
[1999] JOL 5235 (W)
Issue: Rape of a minor

S v Frieslaar
Reference:
[1999] JOL 4755 (C)
Issue: Maintenance

Smith v Smith
Reference:
[1999] JOL 5397 (C)
Issue: Hague Convention

S v Chauke and Another
Reference:
[1999] JOL 5475 (T)
Issue: Theft by a minor

Pearson High School v Head of the Department, Eastern Cape Province and Others
Reference:
[1999] JOL 5517 (Ck)
Issue: Expulsion

Teera v Zumbika
Reference:

[1999] JOL 5713 (ZH)
Issue: Paternity denied by the father

Governing Body of the Tafelberg School v Head of Western Cape Education Department
Reference:
[1999] JOL 5733 (C) | [1999] 4 All SA 573 (C)
Issue: Expulsion

Ismail v Soubai
Reference:
[1999] JOL 5857 (C)
Issue: Fathers rights to their children

S v Mogomane
Reference:
[1999] JOL 5418 (B)
Issue: Trial of a minor

B v B and Another
Reference:
[1999] 2 All SA 289 (A)
Issue: Maintenance of a child

Phillips v Manser and Another
Reference:
[1999] 1 All SA 998 (SE)
Issue: Education

Greyvenstein v Clayton
Reference:
[1999] 1 All SA 156 (E)
Issue: Application for maintenance

Fraser v Naude and Other
Reference:
[1999] (1) SA 1 (CC)
Issue: Adoption: unmarried father’s right to consent

Setti Multilateral Motor Vehicle accidents Funds
Reference:
[1999] (1) SA 1035 (SE)
Issue: Motorist duty of care in respect of children

Davy v Douglas v Douglas and Another
Reference:
[1999] (1) SA 1043 (N)
Issue: Adoption – rescission – assessment

Wicks v Fisher
Reference:
[1999] (2) SA 504 (N)
Issue: Custody – assess – unmarried father

Bursey v Bursey and Another
Reference:
[1999] (3) SA 33 (SCA)
Issue: Duty to support post majority

Meyer v Gerber
Reference:
[1999] (3) SA 650 (O)
Issue: Custody – Child’s views

K v K
Reference:
[1999] (4) SA 691 (CC)
Issue: International Abduction

S v Howells
Reference:
[1999] (1) SACR 675 (CC)
Issue: Best interest of child – sentencing the mother (primary caregiver)

 

1998 Archive

CASES

S v Mokebe
Reference:
[1998] JOL 1363 (B)
Issue: Maintenance

S v Tokata
Reference:
[1998] JOL 1426 (EC)
Issue: Sentencing of child offenders

S v Titus
Reference:
[1998] JOL 1554 (C)
Issue: Maintenance

Mgumane v Setemane
Reference:
[1998] JOL 1757 (TK)
Issue: Maintenance

Davy v Douglas and Another
Reference:
[1998] JOL 1798 (N)
Issue: Access

Sati v Kitsile

Reference: [1998] JOL 1927 (E) | [1998] 1 All SA 530 (E)
Issue: Custody

Kambule v Kambule
Reference:
[1998] JOL 2148 (E) | [1998] 2 All SA 278 (E)
Issue: Custody

S v Dube and others
Reference:
[1998] JOL 2333 (ZH)
Issue: Statutory rape

In Re: Six Juveniles
Reference:
[1998] JOL 2693 (ZH)
Issue: Orders made by Juvenile Court

Naude and Another v Fraser
Reference:
[1998] JOL 2737 (A) | [1998] 3 All SA 239 (A)
| [1998] (8) BCLR 945 (SCA)
Issue: Rights of unmarried fathers

Zhaime v S
Reference:
[1998] JOL 2750 (ZS)
Issue: Sex with a minor

Wicks v Fisher
Reference:
[1998] JOL 3126 (N) | 1998 (9) BCLR 1199 (N)
Issue: Rights of fathers to their illegitimate children

Christian Education South Africa v Minister for Education of the Government of the Republic of South Africa
Reference:
[1998] JOL 3835 (CC)
Issue: Corporal punishment

S v Nkamule
Reference:
[1998] JOL 3949 (T)
Issue: Theft by minor

S v Mashaba
Reference:
[1998] JOL 3885 (T)
Issue: Maintenance

S v Naryan
Reference: [1998] JOL 4132 (W)
Issue: Sentencing of a minor

Phillips v Manser and Another
Reference:
[1998] JOL 4227 (SE) | [1998] 1 All SA 198 (SE)
Issue: Basic education

S v Kika
Reference:
[1998] (2) SACR 428 (W)
Issue: Sentencing the custodial parent

Hlophe v Mahlalela and Another
Reference:
[1998] (1) SA 449 (T)
Issue: Custody – customary law

Van Pletzen v Van Pletzen
Reference:
[1998] (4) SA 95 (O)
Issue: Custody-the concept of ‘mothering’: not only component of women

V v V
Reference:
[1998] (4) SA 169 (CC)
Issue: Custody and Access: best interest

1997 Archive

CASES

T v M
Reference:
[1997] (1) SA 796 (O)
Issue: Adoption by foster parents – biological parents refusing consent

Fraser v Naude and Others
Reference:
[1997] (2) SA 82 (W)
Issue: Adoption – consent by unmarried father

Fraser v Children’s Court, Pretoria North, and Others
Reference:
[1997] (2) SA 218 (T)
Issue: Adoption – consent by unmarried father

B v B and Another
Reference:
[1997] (4) SA 1018 (SE)
Issue: Maintenance post majority

1996 Archive

CASES

Chodree v Vally
Reference:

[1996] (2) SA 28 (W)
Issue:Illegitimate child – Access by natural father

Bethell v Bland and Others
Reference:
[1996] (2) SA 194 (W)
Issue: Custody application by two sets of grandparents

Pike v Minister of Defence
Reference:
[1996] (3) SA 127 (CKS)
Issue: Child’s duty to support parents

Coetzee v Singh
Reference:
[1996] (3) SA 153 (D)
Issue: Illegitimate child-custody – natural father

Van Der Linde v Van Der Linde
Reference:
[1996] (3) SA 509 (O)
Issue: Custody – concept of ‘mothering’

K v Regional Court Magistrate No, and Others
Reference:
[1996] (1) SACR 434 (E)
Issue: Child witness-intermediary procedure

S v Mathebula
Reference:
[1996] (2) SACR 231 (T)
Issue: Child witness-intermediary procedure

1995 Archive

CASES

S v Khumalo
Reference:
[199] (2) SACR 660 (W)
Issue: Child abandonment – Child Care Act

Nguza v Nguza
Reference:
[1995] (2) SA 954 (TK)
Issue: Maintenance – child ‘in the care’ of someone-concept of ‘care’

B v S
Reference:
[1995] (3) SA 571 (A)
Issue: Illegitimate child – Access by natural father

1994 Archive

CASES

McCall v McCall
Reference:
[1994] (3) SA 201 (CC)
Issue: Factors determining the best interest of the child

Skip to content